Modelocracy
Request a list

Claude Haiku 5.5vsGemini 4 Argon

How Claude Haiku 5.5 (Anthropic) and Gemini 4 Argon (Google) rank the 64 lists both answered, measured by how much their lists overlap, weighted toward the top.

Agreement
71%Panel average for a pair: 72%
Among all 45 pairs
11thmost different
Lists compared
64answered by both
Same #1 pick
45of 64 lists

Agreement by list

Overlap between their two lists, weighted toward the top · 100% means identical · Bars take the list's category color · The black tick marks the panel's average for that list

  1. Greatest US presidents98%
  2. Best pizza toppings96%
  3. Greatest soccer players96%
  4. Greatest NBA players96%
  5. Best national parks in the United States95%
  6. Best team knowledge base tools93%
  7. Greatest scientists92%
  8. Best CI/CD platforms92%
  9. Best business intelligence tools91%
  10. Best e-signature software90%
  11. Most influential philosophers90%
  12. Best project management software90%
  13. Best video conferencing software89%
  14. Best cloud data warehouses89%
  15. Best cloud platforms for startups88%
  16. Best SEO tools88%
  17. Best CRM software for small businesses87%
  18. Best US cities for a 30-year-old engineer87%
  19. Best endpoint security software87%
  20. Best team chat apps87%
  21. Best first programming language86%
  22. Best accounting software for small businesses86%
  23. Best ecommerce platforms86%
  24. Best observability tools86%
  25. Best sales engagement platforms85%
  26. Best password managers for businesses83%
  27. Best product analytics tools82%
  28. Best help desk software82%
  29. Greatest TV shows81%
  30. Greatest science-fiction films80%
  31. Greatest board games79%
  32. Best HR software78%
  33. Best Python libraries for reading and editing Excel files78%
  34. Best expense management software76%
  35. Best online form builders76%
  36. Best applicant tracking systems76%
  37. Best national cuisines74%
  38. Best social media management tools73%
  39. Greatest entrepreneurs72%
  40. Greatest video game consoles72%
  41. Best scheduling software72%
  42. Best Python libraries for PowerPoint files71%
  43. Best payroll software69%
  44. Best cloud storage for businesses69%
  45. Best AI coding assistants68%
  46. Best cities in the world to visit67%
  47. Best marketing automation software67%
  48. Best design and prototyping tools66%
  49. Greatest novels65%
  50. Hardest sports to master65%
  51. Best email marketing platforms65%
  52. Best website builders for small businesses62%
  53. Greatest albums49%
  54. Most important scientific discoveries48%
  55. Most influential CEOs of all time43%
  56. Most influential people of the 21st century42%
  57. Most important inventions35%
  58. Best science-fiction novels of the 2010s25%
  59. Most influential companies22%
  60. Best SDKs for AI agents that handle Office and PDF files13%
  61. Best bars for meeting people in San Francisco10%
  62. Best burgers in San Francisco10%
  63. Greatest video games8%
  64. Best chicken wings in San Francisco0%

Where they split hardest

Each model's top 3 on the lists where the two overlap least

Best chicken wings in San Francisco

Food · 0% agreement

Claude Haiku 5.5

  1. 1Wing Wings
  2. 2Mission Chinese Food
  3. 3Brenda's French Soul Food

Gemini 4 Argon

  1. 1San Tung
  2. 2Hot Sauce and Panko
  3. 3Aria Korean Street Food

Greatest video games

Culture · 8% agreement

Claude Haiku 5.5

  1. 1The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
  2. 2Tetris
  3. 3Super Mario Bros.

Gemini 4 Argon

  1. 1The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
  2. 2Super Mario World
  3. 3Red Dead Redemption 2

Best burgers in San Francisco

Food · 10% agreement

Claude Haiku 5.5

  1. 1Super Duper Burger
  2. 2Burger Bar
  3. 3Little Original Joe's

Gemini 4 Argon

  1. 1Nopa
  2. 2Zuni Café
  3. 3Spruce

Only Claude Haiku 5.5

Picks Claude Haiku 5.5 made that Gemini 4 Argon left off the same list · 184 in all, top 10 shown · Highest-ranked first

Only Gemini 4 Argon

Picks Gemini 4 Argon made that Claude Haiku 5.5 left off the same list · 184 in all, top 10 shown · Highest-ranked first

Biggest rank gaps

Picks both listed, at the most different positions · Top 10 · Positions for Claude Haiku 5.5 first, then Gemini 4 Argon

  1. Jack WelchMost influential CEOs of all time#1#14
  2. HeliocentrismMost important scientific discoveries#1#9
  3. Adobe XDBest design and prototyping tools#3#10
  4. AgricultureMost important inventions#7#1
  5. BaseballHardest sports to master#1#7
  6. AppleMost influential companies#1#7
  7. Cal.comBest scheduling software#9#3
  8. Station ElevenBest science-fiction novels of the 2010s#9#3
  9. DNA structureMost important scientific discoveries#10#4
  10. WorkdayBest HR software#4#10

Claude Haiku 5.5 vs the rest

Most alike first

  1. GLM-5.373%
  2. GPT-6 Luna73%
  3. Kimi K373%
  4. Nemotron 3 Ultra72%
  5. Mistral Large 471%
  6. Qwen 3.8 Flash71%
  7. MiniMax M370%
  8. DeepSeek V4 Pro70%

Gemini 4 Argon vs the rest

Most alike first

  1. Kimi K375%
  2. GPT-6 Luna75%
  3. GLM-5.373%
  4. DeepSeek V4 Pro72%
  5. Mistral Large 470%
  6. Nemotron 3 Ultra68%
  7. Qwen 3.8 Flash67%
  8. MiniMax M367%